Skip to main content

Keep vs. Sell Calculator

  • This "rent vs. sell" calculator was built for homeowners with at least $300K of equity.
  • The decision turns on 6 variables; the one most people skip is depreciation recapture ($40K–$120K of unbudgeted tax).

Keep vs. Sell Rental Property Calculator Investor edition

Work through the steps on the left; the results on the right recalculate as you type. Both paths are taxed at the same endpoint so the comparison is apples to apples. Every figure below recalculates as you type.

Step 1 of 5Click a step to open it; opening one closes the others.
1Sale today
What a buyer would pay today. Use a broker opinion or recent comparable sales, not an automated estimate.Redfin home value estimate ↗ Zillow Zestimate ↗ Search recent sales near you ↗
Total paid to both agents. Typically 5–6%. Enter 0 if selling without an agent.Search typical commission in your area ↗
Title, escrow, transfer taxes, attorney fees, as a % of price. Typically 0.5–1.5%.Search seller closing costs in your state ↗
Cash you would spend to get the property ready to list.
Current principal balance on all loans secured by the property. Enter 0 if owned free and clear.Your lender's online statement ↗
2Cost basis and depreciation
What you paid, including purchase closing costs you capitalized.County property records (deed / sale history) ↗
Land is never depreciated. Use the county assessor's land/building split or your closing appraisal. If unsure, 20% of the purchase price is a common estimate.County assessor land vs. building value ↗ Florida property appraiser directory ↗
Additions that raised the property's value or extended its life (new roof, addition, remodel). Routine repairs do not count. Added to basis and depreciated with the building.IRS Pub 527: repairs vs. improvements ↗
Sets the depreciation schedule. Residential rental = 27.5 years; nonresidential = 39 years.IRS Pub 527: recovery periods ↗
Full years the property has been placed in service as a rental. Drives accumulated depreciation, which the IRS recaptures whether or not you claimed it.
Accelerated depreciation claimed beyond the straight-line amount (from a cost segregation study or bonus depreciation). This portion is recaptured at your ordinary rate, not the 25% cap. Enter 0 if none.Your Form 4562 (depreciation) from prior returns ↗
3Your tax situation
Determines your capital gains brackets, NIIT threshold and Section 121 exclusion amount.IRS: what is my filing status? ↗
Your taxable income for the year without the sale (wages, business income, other investments, after deductions). The gain stacks on top of this to decide how much is taxed at 0%, 15% or 20%, and whether NIIT applies.Form 1040, line 15 (taxable income) ↗
Your marginal federal rate (10, 12, 22, 24, 32, 35 or 37). Used for the tax on rental income each year and for recapture of accelerated depreciation.IRS federal tax brackets ↗
Your state's rate on capital gains. Florida, Texas, Nevada, Washington and others with no income tax: 0. California taxes gains as ordinary income up to 13.3%.Search your state's capital gains rate ↗ Tax Foundation state rates ↗
Rental losses from prior years you could not deduct (Form 8582 carryover). They are released when you sell and reduce the taxable gain.Form 8582 (passive loss carryover) ↗
Check if you qualify as a Real Estate Professional, materially participate in a short-term rental, or are under the $100K income allowance. If unchecked, any yearly rental loss is suspended and released at sale.IRS Pub 925: passive activity rules, REPS ↗
4If you keep it
Rent at full occupancy for 12 months, before any expenses.Rentometer rent comps ↗ Zillow rent estimate ↗ HUD Fair Market Rents ↗
Rent you will not collect due to turnover and non-payment. Use 6–10%, never 0.Census rental vacancy rates ↗
Property taxes, insurance, management (about 9% of rent), maintenance (about 1% of value per year), HOA, utilities you pay. Do not include the mortgage or capital reserves.County property tax bill lookup ↗ Search landlord insurance quotes ↗
Total principal and interest paid per year. Monthly payment × 12, excluding escrowed taxes and insurance.Your lender's online statement ↗ Amortization calculator ↗
The part of the yearly payment that reduces the loan balance. From your amortization schedule or lender statement. The rest is interest, which is deductible.Amortization calculator (principal vs. interest) ↗
Set aside for roof, HVAC, water heater, appliances. 5% of gross rent is the standard reserve. Reduces cash flow but is not deductible until spent.Search capex reserve guidance ↗
A known big-ticket item coming up (roof at $25K, HVAC at $12K). Treated as cash out of the keep path.Search replacement costs ↗
Expected yearly price growth. Use your market's actual 5-year trend. Negative values are allowed. This is the single most sensitive input.FHFA House Price Index (by metro) ↗ Zillow Home Value Index data ↗
Both paths are measured at this point in the future. 5 or 10 is typical. Maximum 30.
5If you sell and reinvest
What the after-tax cash would earn elsewhere. 7% is a conservative index-fund base case. Use the interest rate of debt you would pay off, or the cash-on-cash return of a replacement property.S&P 500 historical annual returns ↗ Treasury yields (risk-free benchmark) ↗
Applied to the growth when you cash out at the horizon. 23.8% = 20% capital gains + 3.8% NIIT. Use 0 for paying off debt or a Roth account.IRS Topic 409: capital gains rates ↗ IRS: Net Investment Income Tax ↗
Law & policy defaults (tax year )
These drive the tax math. Update them when the IRS publishes new inflation adjustments or Congress changes the rules. Values shown are federal law for 2026.
Label only.
Straight-line building depreciation is recaptured at your ordinary rate, capped at this. IRC §1(h)(1)(E).IRS Topic 409 (unrecaptured §1250) ↗
IRC §168(c).IRS Pub 527 ↗
Middle bracket rate.IRS Topic 409 ↗
Top bracket rate.IRS Topic 409 ↗
For the filing status selected above. Below this, long-term gains are taxed at 0%.Search current-year IRS inflation adjustments ↗
For the filing status selected above.Search current-year IRS inflation adjustments ↗
Net Investment Income Tax, IRC §1411.IRS: Net Investment Income Tax ↗
For the filing status selected above. Not indexed for inflation: $200K single/HoH, $250K joint, $125K separate.IRS: Net Investment Income Tax ↗
For the filing status selected above. Requires living in the home 2 of the last 5 years. $250K single, $500K joint.IRS Topic 701: sale of your home ↗
Nothing saved yet. Saving keeps your inputs in this browser so they are here when you come back. Nothing is sent anywhere.

Method: Sale proceeds and taxes follow IRS Publication 527 (depreciation allowed or allowable), Publication 551 (adjusted basis), IRC §1(h) (unrecaptured §1250 gain at up to 25%, long-term gains stacked on other income), §1411 (NIIT on the lesser of net investment income or MAGI over the threshold), and §121. Rental cash flow is taxed yearly on NOI less interest less depreciation; losses are suspended unless you can use them. Both paths are valued after tax at the same horizon. This is a planning model, not tax advice. Confirm with your CPA before acting.